COLLECTION ASBESTOS SURVEYS AND TESTING

Asbestos Surveys and Testing for Museum Collections

One object, a store, or the whole collection — scoped with you before anything is touched.

A collection assessment establishes whether asbestos is present in objects rather than in building fabric, and records it in a form a collections team can actually use. We agree the scope with the conservator or collections lead first, review what the accession and conservation records already tell us, map findings to the individual components inside each object, sample selectively where sampling is justified, and return a record linked to accession numbers. Bulk samples are analysed by an independent UKAS-accredited laboratory to ISO/IEC 17025. Where a material cannot be reached safely or sampled without unacceptable loss, it is recorded and managed as a presumption rather than forced.

You Set the Scope

Nothing is opened, moved or sampled until the conservator has agreed what may be touched. The scope is written down before the visit, not after it.

Selective, Not Exhaustive

Sampling everything destroys original fabric for no gain. We sample where the result changes a decision, and presume where it does not.

Component Level

Findings are recorded against the part, not the object. “Contains asbestos” is not actionable; “millboard pad behind the ceramic fuse” is.

Independent Analysis

Samples go to a UKAS-accredited laboratory with no interest in the outcome. You get the certificates with the record, not a summary of them.

What We Assess

Single Objects, Stores and Whole Collections

Most work starts smaller than people expect. A single object assessment is common and often sufficient: an acquisition that needs screening before it comes in, a machine about to be moved, or something a technician has flagged. A store assessment is the next step up — a defined space, prioritised by object type rather than walked shelf by shelf. A collection-wide programme is a different proposition again, and it is usually phased by store or by object category over a period rather than attempted in one pass.

We would generally advise against starting with everything. Screening by function is far more productive than screening by inventory: where an object had to control heat, friction, fire, electrical arcing or pressure, the probability is worth testing; elsewhere the return is low and the cost is real. A programme that assesses the industrial machinery, the electrical collection and the protective equipment first will find most of what is there for a fraction of the cost of a complete survey.

A gloved hand drawing out a shelf tray holding a metal tin in a long aisle of wrapped objects in a museum store

What You Get

What the Assessment Actually Tells You

Four questions, in the order a collections decision needs them.

Is It There?

Confirmed by analysis, recorded as a presumption, or ruled out for the material sampled within the stated scope of that one result.

Exactly Where?

The component and its location within the object, not the object as a whole. A fuse liner, a flange gasket, a cable sleeve, a rope seal.

What Condition?

Condition, accessibility, surface treatment, and any damage or loose debris: what decides urgency, not the material type alone.

Who Could Disturb It?

Which activity, by whom, how often. Handling, mounting, cleaning, opening a case or operating the object all give different answers.

A sealed sample point on the painted casing of a historic machine, with a sample pot and a blank tag on a white cloth

Sampling

Why We Sample Less Than You Might Expect

In a building, sampling is cheap in every sense — a plug out of a ceiling tile costs nothing anyone will miss. In a collection every sample is a small, permanent subtraction from an object someone decided was worth keeping. That changes the calculation completely. The question is not “can this be sampled” but “will the result change what you do”, and where the answer is no, a managed presumption is the better outcome.

So sampling is agreed item by item with the conservator, taken by competent personnel, and kept to what the decision needs. A negative result is treated carefully too: it applies to the material sampled and to the justified scope of that result, not to the whole object. One composite block testing clear says nothing about the gasket behind it. That limitation is stated in the record rather than left for a reader to infer, and it is the single most common way a collections asbestos record gets over-read later.

The Method

Five Steps, and What to Do If Someone Finds Something First

1. Define the Activity

What the assessment is for: acquisition, store survey, move, exhibition, loan, conservation or working demonstration. The purpose decides the scope, and the scope decides the rest.

2. Review the Evidence

Accession records, manufacturer and model data, drawings, repair and conservation history, earlier reports and photographs. Much is answered before anyone attends.

3. Map to Components

Accession number, exact location within the object, product type, condition, accessibility, damage or debris, and who could disturb it, doing what and how often.

4. Sample Selectively

Agreed with the conservator, taken by competent personnel and analysed by a UKAS-accredited laboratory, with the limits of each result recorded.

5. Update the Record

Object and component IDs, confirmed or presumed status, linked results, photographs, limitations, use, restrictions, owner and review triggers.

If Someone Finds Damage

Stop the activity, prevent access and further disturbance, and tell the safety lead. Leave cleaning, opening, moving and sampling until it has been assessed.

The record is the deliverable. The report is just how it arrives.

The Record

Three Things That Make It Worth Having

It Links to the Object

Against the accession number and component, so it travels with the object through a move, a loan or a change of collections system rather than sitting in a PDF.

It States Its Limits

What was assessed, what was not, what a negative result does and does not cover. Over-reading a limited result is how a sound record becomes a problem later.

It Has Review Triggers

Not a date alone. A case opening, a move, a new mount, an impact, a flood, deterioration or a proposal to operate the object all reopen the question, whatever the date.

The Legal Position

What Governs This Work

There is no separate regulation for asbestos in collections. What applies is the general framework: the Control of Asbestos Regulations 2012 govern work liable to expose anyone to asbestos wherever the material sits, and whether a particular task is licensable, notifiable non-licensed or other non-licensed work depends on the material, its condition and what is being done to it rather than on whether the item is building fabric or an accessioned object. Approved Code of Practice L143 explains how the duties are met and carries special legal status — following it is not compulsory, but failing to follow it is treated as evidence of a breach unless compliance is shown another way.

Bulk analysis follows the same standard as anywhere else: samples are analysed against HSE guidance HSG248, the analysts’ guide, by a laboratory accredited to ISO/IEC 17025. Where a museum’s machinery or fixed plant forms part of the premises, the premises duty under Regulation 4 also applies and the two records should cross-reference each other rather than contradict — the asbestos register for the building, and the accession-linked record for the collection. Where air monitoring is needed to assess conditions during a defined activity, that is air monitoring and the same analytical standards apply.

Author: Gordon Ringland, Founder and Director, BOHS P402. Over fifteen years working with asbestos in museum and heritage collections. Reviewed 13 November 2026.

Areas We Cover

Collections Assessment Across the UK

Based in Great Wakering near Southend-on-Sea, we cover Essex, London and the wider South East.

Assessing objects is different from surveying buildings, because the expertise travels rather than the postcode. We regularly assess stores and collections well outside our home region, and a single problem object in a museum anywhere in the UK is a normal enquiry for this service.

Get in Touch

Scope an Assessment

Tell us what the object or collection is, roughly how many items, where they are, what you suspect, and what you are trying to do — acquire, store, move, display, lend, conserve or operate. A deadline helps. Send any existing reports and photographs with the enquiry. Please do not open, move or dismantle anything to photograph it. The object as it stands tells us more than a disturbed one, and a conversation often narrows the scope considerably before anyone attends.

Drag & Drop Files, Choose Files to Upload You can upload up to 3 files.
Please do not open, move or dismantle anything to take a photograph, and never open a respirator filter canister — a picture of the object as it stands is more useful. PDF, Word, Excel, JPG or PNG, up to 3 files, 20MB each.
Where the objects are held, what you suspect and why, and anything already done to them.

Ora Asbestos Management Ltd
Unit 6, Crouchmans Yard, Poynters Lane,
Great Wakering, Essex, SS3 9TS
Hours: Monday–Saturday, 6am–6pm · Closed Sunday

Collection Assessment: Common Questions

A:

One is a perfectly normal engagement. Single-object assessments for acquisitions, moves and flagged items are common and often all that is needed. Larger programmes are usually phased by store or object type rather than attempted in a single pass.

A:

Only where you agree it and where the result would change a decision. Every sample is a permanent subtraction from the object, so the default is to answer the question from records and visual assessment, and to presume where sampling cannot be justified.

A:

That the component is recorded and handled as if it contains asbestos. It is managed, restricted and reviewed on the same basis as a confirmed finding. It is not a gap in the work — in a collection it is frequently the right answer.

A:

It depends what was sampled and what the result was scoped to. A clear result applies to the material sampled, not to the whole object, and a later repair can introduce material the original test never saw. Send us the report and we will tell you what it covers.

A:

That is the intention. Records are produced against accession and component references so they can be imported or entered into whatever system you run, rather than living in a separate document that gets separated from the object.

A:

No. We work where the objects are, in the store or the gallery, and the scope is set around what can be reached safely without moving anything. If something genuinely cannot be assessed in place, that is recorded rather than forced.

A:

An independent UKAS-accredited laboratory, to ISO/IEC 17025. The certificates come back with the record. We do not analyse our own samples, and a laboratory with no interest in the result is worth more to you than a faster turnaround.

A:

Stop the activity, keep people away from it, and do not clean, move or open anything. Tell your safety lead and call us. The first hour matters and almost all of it is about what is not done — see emergency response.